Many people assume that if they had any responsibility for an accident, they cannot bring a claim. In Delaware, that is not true. Delaware law follows a modified comparative negligence rule, which means partial fault reduces your recovery but does not necessarily eliminate it.
The Detailed Answer
Delaware’s comparative negligence statute, 10 Del. C. § 8132, sets the framework for partial fault cases. The rule has three key features.
The 50% Rule
Under Delaware law, you can recover damages from another party as long as your fault is not greater than the combined fault of the parties from whom you are seeking recovery. In practice, this is often summarized as the 50% rule — if you are 50% or less at fault, you can recover. If you are 51% or more, you cannot.
Reduction by Percentage of Fault
If you are within the threshold, your damages are reduced by your share of fault. A jury or adjuster assigns a percentage of fault to each party. Your gross damages are then reduced by your percentage.
Examples
- 10% at fault. Total damages of $100,000 are reduced to $90,000.
- 30% at fault. Total damages of $100,000 are reduced to $70,000.
- 50% at fault. Total damages of $100,000 are reduced to $50,000.
- 51% at fault. No recovery, regardless of how serious the injuries are.
That last category is why fault percentages matter so much in Delaware. The difference between 50% and 51% fault can be the difference between a full claim and no claim at all. This is sometimes called the “51% bar” because at that threshold, recovery is barred entirely.
Common Comparative Negligence Scenarios
Comparative fault arguments come up in many Delaware injury cases:
- Rear-end collisions. The trailing driver is usually presumed at fault, but the lead driver may share fault for sudden stops, broken brake lights, or unsafe lane changes.
- Intersection crashes. Both drivers may have a duty to look out for cross traffic, even when one has a green light.
- Pedestrian accidents. A pedestrian crossing outside a crosswalk may share fault, but Delaware drivers still owe a duty of care.
- Slip and fall. Property owners may argue the injured person was not watching where they were going or ignored warning signs.
- Multi-vehicle pileups. Fault is allocated among multiple drivers based on the sequence of events.
How Fault Is Determined
Fault is determined by the evidence — the police report, witness statements, traffic camera or dashcam footage, vehicle damage analysis, and sometimes accident reconstruction professionals. Insurance adjusters make initial fault determinations, but the final word in a contested case rests with a jury or judge.
Adjusters often try to assign higher fault percentages to injured parties because doing so reduces the carrier’s payout. In a serious injury case, even a 10% or 20% shift in fault can move tens of thousands of dollars. This is why disputed fault cases benefit from careful evidence development.
What This Means for Your Case
If the insurance company is telling you that you were partially at fault, do not assume your claim is over. Two things matter: whether their percentage is correct, and whether it pushes you over the 50% line. A careful review of the police report, witness accounts, and physical evidence can often shift the analysis.
This is particularly important in car accidents with disputed lane changes, intersection collisions, rear-end chains, and pedestrian cases. Premises liability claims, including slip and fall cases, also frequently turn on comparative fault arguments.
Related Questions
Q: What if there are multiple defendants?
When more than one defendant is involved, fault is assigned among all parties. Delaware looks at your fault compared to the combined fault of those you are suing. Apportionment among defendants is governed by the joint tortfeasor rules, which are complex and case-specific.
Q: How is fault percentage decided?
If a case settles, the parties negotiate a fault allocation that is reflected in the settlement number. If a case goes to trial, the jury decides the percentages on the verdict form. The judge then applies the percentages to reduce the award under 10 Del. C. § 8132.
Q: Does comparative negligence apply to workers’ compensation?
No. Delaware workers’ compensation is generally a no-fault system. Whether or not you contributed to your workplace injury, you are typically eligible for medical and indemnity benefits, with limited exceptions for intentional misconduct.
Q: What evidence is most useful in a disputed-fault case?
Independent witness statements, dashcam or surveillance footage, and the physical evidence (vehicle damage patterns, skid marks, debris fields) tend to carry the most weight. Statements taken at the scene by police officers and 911 audio can also be important. The longer you wait to gather this evidence, the more difficult it becomes — businesses overwrite surveillance footage on short cycles, and witnesses move or forget details.
Q: How does comparative fault affect settlement negotiations?
Adjusters often open with a higher fault percentage assigned to the injured party as a negotiating position. A response that documents the actual fault picture — with photographs, witness accounts, and a careful read of the police report — can shift the percentage materially. In serious injury cases, even a five-point swing in fault can move the settlement number by tens of thousands of dollars.
Q: Can a passenger ever be partially at fault?
Rarely, but it can happen — for example, if a passenger distracted the driver, encouraged dangerous driving, or knowingly rode with an intoxicated driver. In most car accident cases, passengers are not assigned fault and can pursue claims against any negligent driver involved.
When to Talk to a Delaware Personal Injury Lawyer
Schuster Jachetti LLP has experience handling Delaware comparative negligence cases, including disputed-fault car accidents, premises liability claims, and catastrophic injury matters where fault percentages can swing settlement value significantly. Joseph M. Jachetti‘s background as a former insurance adjuster gives him a working understanding of how carriers build comparative fault arguments — and how to push back with evidence. Initial consultations are free, and there is no obligation to hire after speaking with us.
Free Consultation
Free consultation. No fee unless we recover compensation for you.
📞 Call (302) 984-1000
This page provides general legal information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice on your specific situation, contact Schuster Jachetti LLP.
Have a Question About Your Case?
Get a free, confidential consultation with a Delaware attorney.
📞 Call (302) 984-1000
This page provides general legal information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice on your specific situation, contact Schuster Jachetti LLP.